GRAMOPHONE (Gramophone ‘Gold Award' Recommended Recording):
Heard in quantity, Arensky's piano works can seem limited and occasionally facile. But heard separately, many of the 38 pieces on this fine CD acquire the status of gems. Salon music in the best sense, such writing is raised by Anthony Goldstone to a still higher level. And, as he points out in his admirable accompanying essay, if Rimsky-Korsakov was dismissive (“he will soon be forgotten”), such disparagement was countered by enthusiasm from both Tchaikovsky and Taneyev.

Here, then, is a stream of encores to surprise and delight an audience. The first of the Op. 63 Preludes is indelibly Russian and so is the peal of bells commencing No. 2. No. 6 looks ahead to Medtner's exquisite Fairy Tale, Op. 9 No. 3, also in G (Arensky's work must surely have lingered in Medtner's prodigiously well stocked mind), while the Forgotten Rhythms are more exploratory, though with memories of Brahms in No. 5. Chopin, too, is remembered in the fourth of the Op. 74 Etudes (his Op. 25 No .12 study), yet, more generally, Arensky runs the gamut of an essentially Russian Romantic pianism. Short in length but often sizeable in virtuoso demands, all this music is played by Goldstone with unflagging musical energy and brio. Volume 5 in Divine Art's Russian Piano Music series is admirably recorded and presented with fine photographs of both the composer and pianist.
Bryce Morrison

FANFARE:
This album of Arensky's shorter piano works was previously issued in 2001, on Olympia 692. It's varied in inspiration: The 12 Etudes of 1905 frequently pay tribute to France—No. 1 in C Major seems especially beholden to Fauré—yet No. 7 in E ? -Major displays the same interest in Wagner as the introduction to the slow movement from Arensky's Symphony No. 2. If the 12 Preludes, Trois Morceaux , and Arabesques owe a great deal to Chopin and Schumann, the six Essais sur des rythmes oubliés display the composer's fascination with metrical and rhythmic experiments. These appealed to his contrarian personality; as Tchaikovsky noted with frustration, whenever he criticized the younger man's obsession with 5/4 time, Arensky would simply use it more often. It may be that Arensky was spurred to his best by such challenges.

Certainly the Borodin-like “Sari” movement finds him in excellent lyrical form, with a game of inversions in its central section, while the 5/4 rhythm and weak-accented primary theme of “Péons” might almost pass for a dance transcribed in the Balkans. Not everything is equally inspired on this album, but there's more than enough in the 12 Etudes and the Essais sur des rythmes oubliés to make up for the longueurs that occasionally appear elsewhere.

Anthony Goldstone performs all of this music in fine fashion, with a connoisseur's appreciation for its elaborate traceries, and shifting expressive patterns. This works especially well in the more intimate selections, such as the Morceaux , although the pianist isn't slow to respond to the expansive vigor required in the “Strophe alcéenne” from the Essais , or the Chabrier-like charms of the Vivace movement from the Arabesques . Technically, he has everything well in hand. The runs and figurations of the Etude No. 6 in D Minor are performed with coruscating finish, and the rubato of the Arabesques ' Tempo di Valse is handled with admirable naturalness. There's plenty of color here, and expressiveness that never sounds forced.

Sound quality is good. Divine Art deserves a nod of thanks for bringing this release, and Goldstone's entire series devoted to piano works by the Russian Romantics, back into print.
Barry Brenesal

MUSICWEB:
One of the most pleasurable voyages of discovery this year has been the ‘Russian Piano Music Series' and in particular the four volumes entrusted to the superbly capable and musically astute care of Anthony Goldstone. This is the third volume I have had the pleasure of reviewing … and I bought the fourth volume for reasons of simple pleasure. The common thread through all of the discs has been the rediscovery of virtuoso piano repertoire from the first half of the last century. Each disc has been hugely satisfying in itself but I would argue that the four together become even more stimulating allowing the listener to compare and contrast the differing musical approaches of four composers from essentially the same Russian Romantic stock.

Anthony Goldstone has proved to be the ideal guide. It is more than just a case of a rock solid technique; in each case he has shown himself not only to be totally attuned to both the core style of the repertoire but crucially, equally at ease with one minute bon-bons or large-scale sonatas. This empathy extends beyond the performances to include some of the most interesting and best written performer liner-notes that I have read; an ideal blend of insight and information. As with the Glière disc previously reviewed this recital of Arensky's music seems to be a straight reissue of an Olympia disc originally released in 2001. All credit to Divine Art for restoring this to the catalogue. This is a programme of miniatures with only two of the 39 tracks running beyond 3 minutes. Even the collections of 12 Preludes Op.63 or 12 Etudes Op.74 have less cumulative impact as a group than the magnificent 25 Preludes Op.30 by Glière which dominate volume 3. Yet it would be quite wrong to assume miniature means slight. Yes, as Goldstone points out, many of these pieces smack more of the Salon than the Steppe yet craft and care and idiomatic piano writing ooze from them at every turn. Goldstone quotes a wonderfully dismissive and sniffy passage from Rimsky-Korsakov's autobiography where the senior composer points to Arensky's penchant for cards and drink that led to his early death at the age of 44 and states rather bleakly; “he will soon be forgotten”. Frustratingly, the dissolute life did mean that both the Preludes and Etudes exist as incomplete half-sets but the pleasures to be had from the music that we do have is considerable. Again as Goldstone points out – well if you will write an astute liner it's going to be quoted! – the influences here are much more Chopin and Schumann rather than fellow Russian nationalists. Given that the two Arensky symphonies are very much in the nationalist tradition it is a little disappointing that his 100+ piano works do not ever grapple with something on a larger more dramatic scale. Instead every movement evokes a beautiful miniature world. I enjoyed in particular the flowing harmonies of Prelude No.6 in G major [track 6] and the lyrical ‘question and answer' of Prelude No.10 in D minor – the smooth ease with which Goldstone navigates this kind of deceptively hard writing indicative of his playing throughout. As in the Glière recital the engineers and producer have created a relatively intimate salon acoustic which I feel suits the music ideally – likewise the chosen piano is perfectly scaled to the repertoire.

If I was forced to choose I would have to say that I found the Lyapunov disc the most revelatory with the Glière not far behind. Both those composers cover a wider musical and dramatic range in the programmes as recorded but then conversely this Arensky is disarmingly charming and gently moving. There is something desperately poignant about a man creating such simple beauty by day and living a nihilistic existence by night. More wide-ranging – in relative terms – are the six Essais sur des rythmes oubliés Op.28 . These are studies in flexible rhythm which Arensky exploits to try and lose predictable bar lines. Hence he uses a 5/4 time signature some years before Tchaikovsky did in his final symphony. Curiously, for all their attempts to be more radical at 120 years distance they sound more harmonically conservative with the rhythmic ‘novelty' barely registering. But they are all adorned with some ravishing filigree writing that again Goldstone plays with artless ease and the subtlest rubato – this really is a master-class in the playing of this style of music. As befits their title the 12 Études are more overtly technical and as such less immediately charming; that being said the harp-like cascades of No.5 in D major [track 23] are instantly beguiling. The disc is completed with two shorter compilations of pieces with the six Arabesques Op.67 being the music of least consequence on the disc. But all credit to Goldstone for not trying to impose a ‘meaning' where one does not try to exist; this is graceful elegant music. The disc is completed with one final nonchalant – but brutally hard – Etude – which you could imagine as the encore to a superb recital, all easy wit and technical display couched in winningly charming terms. And that is just how it sounds here – a superb conclusion * to a triumphant series of discs in which Mr Goldstone can take enormous pride. Proof if proof were needed that music does not need to always storm the heavens to be life-enhancing. Bravo!
Nick Barnard

* note - conclusion only to the initial set of discs - more to come from Anthony Goldstone, Sergei Dukachev, Murray McLachlan and more great pianists

PIANIST (joint review of 25081, 25083, 25084, 25085):
More Russian repertoire comes from the pianist Anthony Goldstone who has probably the widest palette of all – and surely the brightest of all waistcoats. Goldstone is known for his extensive series of four-handed recordings with Caroline Clemmow and his solo recordings are all of immense interest. Readers may remember my job over his recent release of music inspired by dances. Here Goldstone embarks on a (long, I hope) series of Russian piano music. Composers who lived now brought out into the daylight: Arensky, with his tuneful Preludes: Lyapunov, a minor Liszt follower: Glière, more known for his large-scale orchestral music: and the least-known Rebikov, who was, however, immortalised by his Christmas Tree , once a stalwart of piano score anthologies. All of Goldstone's discs are highly satisfying, played with power and conviction and if there are not true masterpieces among the many smaller works, they are far more rewarding to listen to than many of the minor British composers living in the shadow of Elgar and Vaughan Williams.
Marius Dawn Pianist Recommended Recording

CLASSICALNET:
This disc, the fifth instalment in Divine Art's mini-cycle dedicated to Russian Piano Music, features the keyboard music of Anton Arensky. Born in 1861, Arensky's career ran parallel with some of Russia's most famous composers like Rimsky-Korsakov and Tchaikovsky to mention but two, so his life's work tends to be somewhat overshadowed by the achievements of his contemporaries. Still his music, that includes symphonies, concertos, chamber and instrumental pieces is extremely well crafted, and a strong melodic vein is a constant feature. Unfortunately, just like Mussorgsky, he was a compulsive gambler and drinker not to mention other vices, and as a result his health started deteriorating at an early age. He died in 1906 from sepsis due to an infected insect bite, not yet age 45.

The piano works that make up this issue reveal a master miniaturist. Many of the pieces last just over a minute, but their idiomatic timbre and graceful subtlety make them highly attractive creations. Indeed, the one real remarkable feature is their understatement and lack of bombast, but overall there is much that one can admire and enjoy.

AMERICAN RECORD GUIDE: (comparative review with Naxos CD by Adam Neiman)
Anton Stepanovich Arensky (1861-1906) is remembered today for a bare handful of his compositions and as the teacher of Scriabin, Rachmaninoff, and Gretchaninoff. His short life, addicted to gambling and alcohol, ended at a sanatorium in Finland where he died of tuberculosis. His music shows the influence, if not the genius, of Tchaikovsky; and it is enjoyable, well crafted, melodic, and not without charm. In these two recordings of his piano music the only duplication is the set of 12 Etudes, Op. 74.

The Etudes show a real difference between these two performers. Neiman, the American pianist, is sweepingly lyrical. Everything flows smoothly, with rippling motion—lots of arpeggios.

Goldstone, from England, is more dramatic and modern in sound. His recording was originally on the Olympia label—and favorably reviewed at the time (Nov/Dec 2001). He sometimes finds the angularity and odd inflection in the music. But both recordings are excellent.

[In] Goldstone's selection, the 12 Preludes Op. 63 are virtuosic and well contrasted. They resemble Chopin only in their fecundity, and each one seems to beget another as they flow forth in a natural manner. The Essays on Forgotten Rhythms are said to take their rhythms from the poetry of ancient Greece and Rome. While the first employs left hand arpeggios, the second is characterized by catchy rhythms. The remaining four convince us that Arensky has a first-rate melodic gift; there is much that is very beautiful, and nothing falls short of elegant.

A Suite of Arabesques, Op. 67, and the three pieces of Op. 42 complete Goldstone's selection. If not revelatory or particularly innovative, they are interesting and increase one's admiration for the composer. While all these pieces are short, they rarely reek of the salon, and usually manage to bring smiles to the face of the listener. Goldstone is a wonderful interpreter, and people enamored of the piano will be considerably poorer if they do not invest in this.

While Goldstone offers his own informative notes, Naxos does a reasonably good job in that department as well. Further confusing matters is the outstanding recital on Hyperion from Stephen Coombs. While there is much duplication, his gentle playing exudes charm and forces me to have all three on my shelves.
Becker

MUSICA (Italy) (joint review of vols 1-5):
This is a nice collection of CDs of the Russian piano repertoire. The next two are soon to be released [and are now available on divine art dda25095 and 25096] , but the fact that they will include Rachmaninov's and Prokofiev's pieces makes them less interesting, at least for their rarity. While, instead, recordings completely devoted to works by Arensky, Lyapunov, Glière and Rebikov are not released every day. On this our acknowledgements go to the British company [Divine Art], new on the Italian market.. The interpreter of the four single-composer CDs and also the author of the excellent informative notes included is Anthony Goldstone; while the first CD of the collection, which features several composers, is interpreted by Murray McLachlan: Kabalevsky's and Shostakovich's sonatas are not new to the record industry, but the pieces by Myaskovsky, Stevenson and Shchedrin – though not at their first recording here – can be considered real rarities.

The four composers of the monographic CDs represent, in the Russian music scene, as many different positions, equidistant from both Romanticism and Impressionism, for sure closer to Tchaikovsky than to Mussorgsky and the Group of Five; and in the case of Rebikov and Glière, who died in 1920 and 1956 – the modernistic poetics from the 20th century.

Having lived a short and profligate life, Anton Arensky left less rich a production than he could have. Still, he wrote a hundred pieces for piano, inspired by the romanticism of Chopin and Tchaikovsky, which informed his work to the utmost. He also taught Rachmaninov and Scriabin. These days Arensky is mainly renowned for the lovely waltz from the first Suite for two pianos, but his Studies and Preludes are valuable too; and mainly the six Essais sur des rythmes oubliées , Op.28, with its unusual metres.

Sergei Lyapunov (who lived a longer and more sober life than Arensky but one which was no more productive) was also a great romantic, in the line of Chopin, Liszt and Anton Rubinstein, but in his works the popular Russian tradition is more present, because he was a close friend and pupil of Balakirev, father of the “Five”, who dedicated to Lyapunov the Sonata for piano he finally completed in 1905. In answer to this Lyapunov composed the Sonata Goldstone plays here. If Arensky is renowned for his lovely waltz, works by Lyapunov are performed too every now and then, mainly during the conservatoire exams: especially some of the twelve Transcendental Studies that complete the tonal cycle Liszt started with his works of this name. The CD includes the sonata and some other works, the well-known Fêtes de Noël , Op.41, among them.

Vladimir Rebikov, the third of these composers to be born in the 1860s, died in 1920; though far less renowned than the two abovementioned, he produced a much more innovative musical language: Stravinsky himself mentions him in this sense. His innovations anticipate certain harmonic aspects of the 20th century (whole-tone system, unresolved harmonies, pieces without bars and metre, tone clusters). At the beginning of the CD Goldstone performs two short pieces where Rebikov anticipates two moments that are reminiscent of both Stravinsky ( Le sacre du printemps ) and Messiaen ( Quatuor pour la fin du temps ). Apart from this peculiarity, Rebikov's piano production, also because of his natural bent for teaching, is made up of short and very short pieces (on the CD sixteen out of forty-three last less than one minute). However, there is also a major work, a ‘tableau musical-psycologique' entitled Esclavage et liberté (Op.22). Other oddities: a cycle of seven pieces that lasts three minutes and a half ( Une fête , Op.38) and one out of four pieces written without accidentals, on white keys only ( Chansons blanches , Op.48).

While Rebikov and Lyapunov died shortly after the establishment of the Soviet regime, Reinhold Glière lived all through the period of Stalinism, outliving the dictator himself by three years. As a composer he remained a traditionalist Romantic, and he didn't reject the opportunity to celebrate a few feasts of the new regime with his music. Also Glière wrote short pieces for piano, mainly in Chopin's tradition but as well in that Russian piano music style of the day, led by the influence of Scriabin. A wonderful pianist, Arensky's and Taneyev's pupil, he reached his creative peak in the 25 Preludes Op.30 ( twenty-five as he adds to the series – which follows Bach's, not Chopin's harmonic order – one last Prelude in C major, just as Alkan did): an impressive, extremely varied and interesting series. The spirit of Chopin, inherited through his Polish mother, marks Glière's short Mazurka (Op.29), and the eloquent simplicity of the Esquisses Op.47 betrays educational, but mostly appropriate, intentions. As for his discography, Anthony Goldstone is an interpreter we can't overlook. The repertoire he presents is not just special and precious, but also put forward with remarkable cultural intelligence: each one of his CDs can be said to develop a theme. This knowledge of the various repertoires also enables him to move with extreme versatility from genre to genre, from composer to composer, from character to character: from the sentimentalism, a little frivolous, of some of Arensky's pieces, to the irony of work by Rebikov; from Lyapunov's Russian-style harmonies to the cyclical integrity of Glière's Preludes , everything performed through the vaguely archaic sound of a Grotrian piano, Goldstone convinces and charms us.
Riccardo Risaliti